Saturday, January 5, 2008

Renegades

This is taken from our parish website:

To be considered a candidate for celebrating the Sacraments of Reconciliation and Holy Communion a child must be:
· Baptized in the Catholic tradition…AND
· At the age of discretion, understanding right from wrong,
Usually 7 years of age…AND
· Has completed a full year (2006/2007) of formal foundational catechesis (attending weekly Christian Education Classes or attending a Catholic School)…AND
· Currently enrolled and attending formal catechesis for the year of 2007/2008…AND
· All families (parent along side their child) participate in the Sacramental Preparation. This is a free standing preparation separate and in addition to your child’s weekly Christian Education Class/Catholic School…AND
· Families should be attending Sunday Mass…AND
· A Copy of your child’s Baptismal Certificate needs to be received and attached to the registration form…AND
· If your child did not attend Christian Education Classes/Catholic School at SEAS for the year of 2006/2007, you will need to attach proof from the Church where your child attended…AND
· A $25 book/materials fee covers both sacraments

I scoff - SCOFF, I say! - in the face of these requirements. Call me old-fashioned, but I think it's the parents' duty to instruct our children in the faith. Here's a lovely quote from the modern Catechism:

“The role of parents in education is of such importance that it is almost impossible to provide an adequate substitute. The right and the duty of parents to educate their children are primordial and inalienable.”
--- CCC 2221


We believe that the principle of subsidiarity applies even to DRE's. So, we're going renegade. (Cue the bad-ass music.)

We've been working through the good old Baltimore Catechism with Bobcat for the past four months. We've been evaluating his progress, conversing with him, reiterating certain key ideas through routine conversations. Basically, making sure that he is ready to receive worthily. It's going really well. Obviously no one fully understands the great mysteries of our faith, but for his age, he seems to understand pretty well, and is excited about it.

All that's left to do is get the January mass assignments from the parish and pick a date. I'm a little nervous that some church employees would be ruffled by us just showing up without going through the "proper channels", but we'll choose one of the friendly, older priests. We will probably make it a Friday evening, so the church is not crowded and we won't have any trouble sitting all together.

I hope it goes well, because I suspect that a number of others from our homeschool group may wish to follow the same formula. We're not the only ones put off by the many requirements listed above. After all, first communion is not even a recorded sacrament. There's no certificate required, as with baptism, in order to get confirmed and married later in life. The parish has no right to deny the sacraments of the church. (I couldn't find the catechism reference regarding denying sacraments to those who ask for them, but I know it can only be done if the would-be recipient is living in an obvious, public, and scandalous state of grave sin. Surely that doesn't apply to a seven-year-old!)

So, we'll let you all know how it goes. And then we'll party, and you'll all be invited!

8 comments:

Charlotte (WaltzingM) said...

The biggest issue I have is that our own parishes don't consider our homeschools "Catholic Schools" but the State of Texas does!? Say what???

Elizabeth said...

Hmmm...I'm wondering about our parish.

Bob's Blog said...

You are not renegades. You just have the ability to think for yourselves. Last time I checked, that is not a crime. It's your choice of basketball teams that I'm worried about.
P.S. Did you notice that the Nuggets beat the Spurs the other night?

MommaLlama said...

Bob: I did see that... so did we on our most recent meeting with them. I also noticed they have the Nuggets right ahead of in standing, but you're goin' down!
:-).

Steph B said...

I just wanted to make a couple comments about this topic, speaking as a DRE for a different parish...

Firstly, all of those requirements are not particular to your parish. Those requirements are put out by the Bishop. The Bishop is charged with ensuring that the people in his diocese are well catechized and prepared to receive the sacraments (all the sacraments). You are correct when you say that you cannot deny someone a sacrament. That is one of the fundamental principles in canon law. However, the bishop (through pastors and DREs) can recommend postponing the reception of a sacrament if a person is not prepared or "worthy" to receive (Eucharist and Matrimony are the sacraments where this comes up most often... and people are commonly denied the sacrament of ordination). I agree that you guys are probably better educated in the faith than many parishioners. However, the requirements are in place so that parents who are not as well prepared know the minimum standard they need to achieve with their child. Also, there are some fundamental concepts that people should understand and accept before receiving Communion. Not all parents know which concepts are central and should be understood before Communion.

You are also correct in saying that parents are the primary educators of faith. However, not all parents are prepared or equipped to be the sole educators of faith for their children. That is where the parish and Catholic schools come in. Additionally, it is within the rights of the bishop to determine what materials are acceptable for use in catechesis. That is why the USCCB has developed the approved text book list.

Even though I am in a different diocese, these are also the requirements for our parish (they are actually pretty standard requirements across the nation). I do actually recognize home schools as a "Catholic School" if they use an approved text. I’m sorry your parish does not.

It is the pastor's right (given to him by the bishop) to determine if a child is ready to receive a sacrament. And, fyi, we do actually keep a record book of who receives first Communion. A pastor can give permission for a person to bypass some of the requirements (as long as the child is baptized) if he feels the child is prepared.

I know this turned into a long post. I hope I didn’t offend you. I just felt like I should defend DREs and the requirements for receiving first Communion.

Take Care. I hope the big day goes well.

nicole said...

We got our email invite. We have Apostolate on Fridays usually, so I can't RSVP yet. How exciting for your family though!

Charlotte (WaltzingM) said...

Dear Steph B.,

While it is true that the rules and regulations were established to help the Bishops and pastors deal with the large number of uneducated parents one would have to ask... how did they get to be so uneducated assuming they all followed the guidelines of CRE?

In other words, if all parents, were doing their job like the Llama family, there wouldn't be a need for DREs in fact, the position is only a modern invention. The Church survived quite a number of years without them. People talked to their pastors and their pastors knew them by name. No one had to call and speak to a receptionist who then transfered them to an assistant who then took a message for a DRE to call them back.

Now, just because there are parents today who gladly turn over the responsibility of raising and caring for their children to a whole host of people (daycare workers, lunch ladies, principals, teachers) why should the Llama's be denied their God given rights to be the sole caretakers and guardians of their children's education? Punish the innocent to catch the guilty?

DREs should be there to serve the parents since they are the primary educators and care takers. There might be some families who need more help than others. There might be some families that need more rules and regulations. Why the one size fits all mentality? Well, I think the public school mentality has been incredibly pervasive and as hard as some people have worked to change the minds of the secular leaders regarding homeschooling, the same must now be done for our Church leaders. The good Bishops need to wake up and smell the coffee of the 21st century and realize that homeschooling is here to stay. Again, I say... my own state doesn't place any of the demands on me as the primary educator of my children that my geographical parish does. I don't have to use textbooks or turn in work. I don't have to keep records or submit my children for examination. Yet, the Church demands this?

Now, before you think I am attacking your position, let me just say that I have two children who have made their First Holy Communion and it was at our parish with our most excellent priest who did determine for himself that they were ready to receive Our Lord. It wasn't hard for him to know the state of their souls and level of understanding as he had been hearing their confession for several months before they made FHC.

When it was time for them to receive the Sacrament, they did so quietly at Mass with us around them. There was no fanfare or special activities to distract from the beauty of the Mass. The other parishioners were not inconvenienced and the Mass was no longer than usual. So I agree that the pastors are the ones who have the authority. But when they choose to abdicate that responsibility it is innocent families that suffer. And considering that Our Lord chose to be born into a family, I would think that our Church would be most concerned with honoring and protecting them.

Daddio said...

I disagree with the statement that "...not all parents are prepared or equipped to be the sole educators of faith for their children." Perhaps many are not prepared, but ALL are equipped by virtue of the graces received in holy matrimony. One sort of good thing about our parish's program is that they require the parents to attend the class with the children. But they shouldn't be "teaching" the class, they should be "equipping" the parents to teach it to their children directly, rather than handing it all over to the church ladies.

I didn't say DRE's were unnecessary (not saying I disagree with Matilda... just not saying that I said it...), and I do appreciate the logistics of administering a very large parish or diocese. However, the principle of subsidiarity demands that the DRE and CCD program serve the parents, at the parents' pleasure. I don't feel that our parish is willing to accommodate parents who opt out of the formal program. In other words, they don't know their place. Their motives are good - to make sure the children are truly prepared - but it becomes a kind of power grab.